Re:Harry Potter the Musical? - 2007/09/29 14:22broadway4LIFE wrote: only reason i would go to see it - see how they pull it off.
Yes! Truthfully I don't have a lot of faith in this (even as a HP fan) and am frightened for Broadway (if this rumor happens to be true - wouldn't be surprised, there's even a HP theme park in the works!)Name: Devyn
| | The administrator has disabled public write access.
itshairspray
User Supporting Player
Posts: 139
Karma: 2
Re:Harry Potter the Musical? - 2007/11/26 12:02I kind of hate to admit it because I'm afraid of the the tomatoes that might be thrown but I'm kind of excited. I love Harry Potter and if they do it right, it might be kind of cool. But it won't ruin Harry Potter, even if the result is kind of shoddy. Harry Potter is not able to be ruined. It's that magical. :]Upcoming: Fall Play (???) Currently: Finishing Summer Reading and Playing High School Musical: Sing It Past: Henrietta (Honk Jr.)
| | The administrator has disabled public write access.
mslexy403
User Chorus Member
Posts: 65
Karma: 0
Re:Harry Potter the Musical? - 2007/11/26 14:39ising88 wrote: don't they remember the horrible disaster that was LOTR: the musical in England?! You can't satisfy the mass public with staging once they've seen the special effects that film offers.
I saw LOTR in London. It was fantastic, but then again, that's just me. I think it'd be pretty popular. I'd go see it!
The thing that I did NOT like about LOTR was they did combine all three movies/books together into a three hour musical, but I still loved it. It'd be near impossible to do that with Harry Potter. They'd have to take out a lot and juts focus on every time he faces Voldemort which would be annoying. I know that i'd be frustrated if they adapted or cut out some stuff, so I think that'd be it. But hell, it's so popular, why not bring it to the stage! I think it's a cool idea. Don't hate me..please!
Post edited by: mslexy403, at: 2007/11/26 14:42"If life seems jolly rotten, there's something you've forgotten. And that's to laugh and smile and dance and sing"
Currently: Nothing! So sad..
Favorite Roles: Cosette in Les Miserables
Dream Roles: Lady of the Lake (Spamalot), Val (A Chorus Line), Millie Dillmount (Thoroughly Modern Mille)
| | The administrator has disabled public write access.
itshairspray
User Supporting Player
Posts: 139
Karma: 2
Re:Harry Potter the Musical? - 2007/11/26 15:25If they decide to make a Harry Potter musical, i think they should focus on the last two books in the series. They are perhaps the most informative, dramatic books in the series. Maybe at the beginning, they have a little montage or something about Harry's life before hogwarts and and then the next few years. They can make a song out of it and then after a bit go right into the last two books or just the last one. For example, at the beginning of Wicked, they talk about Elphaba being born, you know, her beginnings. Something like that would be neat. :]Upcoming: Fall Play (???) Currently: Finishing Summer Reading and Playing High School Musical: Sing It Past: Henrietta (Honk Jr.)
| | The administrator has disabled public write access.
Intoxication
User Chorus Member
Posts: 47
Karma: 1
Re:Harry Potter the Musical? - 2007/11/28 15:21Thefre is no way the can fit the plot in to a musical so I wonder what they'll do but hey with LOTR the music was a disator but teh set costume aspect was absolutely stunning I'd say it would go like that with Harry Potter. Harry Potter will make probably a bad musical but I will go see it I honestly could do with a good laugh.
but then again legally blond was much better than expected....Currently Combeferre
Fate ,inks thee to me forever and a day
| | The administrator has disabled public write access.
akrialet
User Chorus Member
Posts: 41
Karma: 0
Re:Harry Potter the Musical? - 2008/01/10 14:38I think the special effects are the least of their worries. If we recall Merlin the Musical, that show had AWESOME special effects. However, the story (or lack of one) was the killer. Like Harry Potter, the whole concept of Merlin was an extremely popular one, but once the show actually came out, it was disappointed. It would be an egregious mistake to put all of the books into one show, but I think it would also be weird to start in the middle of the story.
I don't know, haha. My favorite book was the first one, because it was the one that gave us the greatest look into the life of being a student at Hogwarts with the classroom scenes and whatnot. I think if a musical were to be made from HP, I would like to see the first book Micah--- [Not the boy who lives next door] Current Role: The Baker in Into the Woods!!!!!
| | The administrator has disabled public write access.
brucecriesxout
User Supporting Player
Posts: 284
Karma: 7
Re:Harry Potter the Musical? - 2008/01/17 11:32akrialet wrote: I think the special effects are the least of their worries. If we recall Merlin the Musical, that show had AWESOME special effects. However, the story (or lack of one) was the killer. Like Harry Potter, the whole concept of Merlin was an extremely popular one, but once the show actually came out, it was disappointed. It would be an egregious mistake to put all of the books into one show, but I think it would also be weird to start in the middle of the story.
I don't know, haha. My favorite book was the first one, because it was the one that gave us the greatest look into the life of being a student at Hogwarts with the classroom scenes and whatnot. I think if a musical were to be made from HP, I would like to see the first book
Haha then it would be like a series of musicals! I can see it already.Name: Bruce Current Production: None. Upcoming Auditions:
The Butler Did It Singing (Chandler)
| | The administrator has disabled public write access.
bjgruber
User Chorus Member
Posts: 24
Karma: 0
Re:Harry Potter the Musical? - 2008/01/17 14:33I see how it could be done. I just don't see how it could be done well.Favorite Shows: Spring Awakening, Avenue Q, Hairspray, Assassins, Parade Dream Role: Melchior or Moritz/Spring Awakening Current Role: Bishop/Comberferre in Les Miserables Upcoming Auditions: Busch Gardens, Thoroughly Modern Millie, All Shook Up, VCU (Classical)
| | The administrator has disabled public write access.
AmandaC
User Supporting Player
Posts: 263
Karma: 1
Re:Harry Potter the Musical? - 2008/01/17 21:02bwaybound77 wrote: Yes! Truthfully I don't have a lot of faith in this (even as a HP fan) and am frightened for Broadway (if this rumor happens to be true - wouldn't be surprised, there's even a HP theme park in the works!)
Haha, just laughing at that because now there actually is an HP theme park in the works!!
And I hope this is true...do we know yet? Despite the fact the sotry wouldn't be good, the music could be really fun for an HP fan...and a "dancing Lucius Malfoy" would be heaven!! I want this to be true, just because I think it could be really funny and possibly good. It'd be cute!! If it is true I'd rather they just picked one main storyline and did it...condensing 7 years into one show would be hard and would come out badly.
Post edited by: AmandaC, at: 2008/01/17 21:03The opposite of Rent is Oklahoma!!! Why didn't I think of that?
| | The administrator has disabled public write access.
lanilovesyew
User Chorus Member
Posts: 60
Karma: 0
Re:Harry Potter the Musical? - 2008/04/25 19:38oh my lord. i really do NOT think this is a good idea. seven books of greatness into one show??? honestly, they are crazy...Current Role: Louise Lerman/Eve (Judy's Assistant) in "Ruthless!" by Marvin Laird. Recently: Lala Levy in "The Last Night of Ballyhoo" by Alfred Uhry. blog:: thedramagirl.blogspot.com
| | The administrator has disabled public write access.
lanilovesyew
User Chorus Member
Posts: 60
Karma: 0
Re:Harry Potter the Musical? - 2008/04/25 19:40Intoxication wrote: but then again legally blond was much better than expected.... LMAO!!! This is true...Current Role: Louise Lerman/Eve (Judy's Assistant) in "Ruthless!" by Marvin Laird. Recently: Lala Levy in "The Last Night of Ballyhoo" by Alfred Uhry. blog:: thedramagirl.blogspot.com
| | The administrator has disabled public write access.
